UbiGreen is a project that tries to answer the question of how to design for the small screen of mobile devices in order to provide feedback on people's transportation behavior and positively influence their environmental awareness. Thanks to feedback about the transportation activity, people could be encouraged to choose more environmentally friendly modes of transportation. Such an aim of this project is motivated by the fact, that in the United States the transportation is the third largest contributor to CO2 emission.
First part of the project was a formative study of the transportation habits, which consisted of two phases, an online survey and experience sampling method (ESM). The ESM was performed in order to confirm whether participants actually act in the way they described in the survey.
After the study of habits was done, the researchers conducted a field study using the mobile application they developed called UbiGreen. The application shows iconic feedback that provides personalized awareness of the users' green actions. The icon based feedback was chosen considering the responses from the earlier study, as being the most intuitive one. The background screen of the phone was updated when "green" actions were detected. The activity was detected semi automatically - the study required to wear an additional tracking device, which was reported by participants to be troublesome, however researchers propose a mitigation to this problem by using a phone with built in accelerometer in future studies (new version is shown in the YouTube video above).
![]() |
| Two designs shown to two groups of study participants. |
Lastly, the field study provided a series of interesting results that could be a guide to designers of future technology that would try to provide feedback on people's actions:
- CO2 savings were not most important factor, people liked additional data such as calories used by walking, potential money savings
- Participants felt that it's difficult to estimate CO2 and they would like to see a progress bar of their current "savings"
- Participants liked a combined iconic and numerical feedback
- Negative-reinforcement would be another useful way to influence people behavior
- The designs of visual feedback should not be repetitive
- Some participants felt that visual feedback was not sufficient to influence their habits w.r.t transportation
- Real-time suggestions based on data gathered would be attractive to participants
- Many participants naturally perceived the application and visual feedback as a game and perceived feedback as points and felt cheated if a green action was not correctly detected by the sensing system
- Most participants did not feel that the application influenced their behaviour, stating that they were already trying to travel in pro-environment manner
Citation:
Proceeding CHI '09 Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, ACM, New York, NY, USA ©2009
Project website: http://dub.washington.edu/projects/ubigreen
Paper DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/1518701.1518861

No comments:
Post a Comment